Iran-Israel: The Diplomatic Turns that Ended Twelve Days or War

The conflict between Israel and Iran, now dubbed the “12-Day War” by United States President Donald Trump, provides a multilayered lesson on the role of diplomacy in today’s rapidly changing global arena. Considering the big personalities of the political leaders involved, and the erratic, seemingly personal nature of their actions to calm the crisis, one could assume that diplomacy played a very minor role in its resolution. After all, wasn’t it simply a matter of President Trump’s agendas and desires that took center stage in both Israel and Iran? Wasn’t diplomacy resorted to only after the use of brute force and bunked busting bombs? The 30,000-pound bombs known as Massive Ordinance Penetrators (MOPs) are considered to be the proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back on two fronts: they were said to significantly set back Iran’s nuclear program, and they pushed the fighting parties to agree to a ceasefire. However, the reality is more complicated and that the role played by diplomacy is greater and more influential than it may appear.

War in the middle of diplomatic negotiations

First, we should remember that this war began within a diplomatic context. Iran and the US were engaged in negotiations on a new nuclear deal for weeks before Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu ordered an attack on Iran – an attack that was obviously premeditated rather than “preemptive.” In fact, I would suggest that it was precisely the possibility of a “diplomatic solution” or agreement between the US and Iran that frightened Israel enough to launch the attack. Israel’s emerging security doctrine amounts to a rejection of any but the most tactical and logistical diplomacy. Israel wants the recognized right to attack whoever it wants, wherever it wants and for as long as it wants without taking responsibility for the consequences. The idea that Iran and the US might reach a diplomatically brokered solution, one that would assign responsibilities and list consequences, was perceived by Israel as a direct threat.

Second, diplomacy played an active role throughout the conflict. Despite Israel’s overt and intentional flouting of international law and protocol, Iran dispatched its Foreign Minister, Abbas Araghchi, to meet with a large number of regional and global leaders. Iran pursued its case against Israel through various diplomatic means, from obtaining regional condemnation to statements in the United Nations, citing the relevant articles in international legal instruments and calling for their enforcement. It was Israel, in fact, that rejected diplomacy and claimed the exclusive right not just to determine threats to itself and “world peace,” but also to use all the means at its disposal to dispose of these “threats.” It does not seem far-fetched to assume that Iran’s diplomatic endeavors played a part in shaping President Trump’s understanding of the evolving crisis. While President Trump chose to strike Iran’s nuclear facilities, he did not do so repeatedly and did not join Israel’s offensive efforts on any other front. President Trump’s calls for a deal immediately after the strike alongside his willingness to enforce the ceasefire through the use of unprecedented means demonstrate Trump’s instinctive understanding that armed conflicts are easily initiated but are much more difficult to terminate on the battlefield. (I have never seen an American president force an Israeli PM to turn back Israeli fighter pilots).

Big declarations likely backed by strenuous diplomatic work

While it was President Trump who took center stage with his declarations, there is little doubt that these were preceded and accompanied by strenuous diplomatic work. Since assuming office President Trump had made numerous baseless statements on everything from Gaza to international tariffs. These quickly faded away, ignored even by President Trump almost as soon as they were uttered. Still, in the case of the 12-Day War most of Trump’s statements – including the seemingly unilateral declaration of a ceasefire – turned out to be corroborated by both Israel and Iran. Iran’s “attack” on the Al Udeid Air Base in Qatar was fully coordinated with the Qataris with the Americans allegedly informed ahead of time. Iran appears to have coordinated with the US government messaging, with the spokesman of the Foreign Ministry stating that the nuclear facilities were “badly hurt” without offering detail, even as the Defense Intelligence Agency reporting that the Iranian nuclear program had been set back merely by a few months.

In summary, diplomacy has played a very significant part in all stages of the 12-Day war. Israel appears to be the only party that assumed it is free to act without employing diplomatic means. When President Trump forced the Israeli fighters to turn back as they were en route to Iran, he rebuked Israel publicly for bucking diplomatic channels. This rebuke likely signals that the US did not serve as Israel’s accomplice in the attack but was rather notified and consulted. It is also reasonable to assume that the US and Iran maintained a conversation throughout these 12 days. Diplomacy is not a first option for both President Trump and PM Netanyahu, for both their vision of security is personal, contextual and based on rapid response to evolving situations. Nonetheless, diplomacy remains the bedrock of international relations. Good, stable diplomatic are an asset to be prized and cultivated, even in the midst of brash rhetoric and military strikes. Still, even the brashest of leaders counts on his diplomats to provide him both access to and a platform for conversation. Leaders, like PM Netanyahu, who view the current state of affairs as a laissez passer for unrestrained violence and discretion, are likely to be unpleasantly surprised.

 

Ori Goldberg is an independent Israeli analyst and university professor who has written extensively on Iran, Israel and the relationship between religion and politics in the Middle East. 

Share this article:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email

Related Posts

In Brief

Latest News

Our monthly analysis on diplomacy, mediation and conflict resolution is trusted by scholars, leaders and researchers from around the world.

By signing up for Diplomacy Now, you can expect to receive expert analysis on mediation and conflict resolution straight to your inbox, every month.