Edition 38 – Diplomacy Undone

Global diplomacy has taken some unexpected turns this month, with the big powers battling at the United Nations Security Council over Western Sahara, a conflict that has been running for more than 50 years. The United States administration whipped out its lasso and tried to reel in Western Sahara for its newfound ally, Morocco. Instead, in a major upset for the US and Morocco, Russia vetoed the resolution, and put forth a short counterresolution that was also rejected. With no renewal of its mandate, the fate of the Mission for the Referendum in Western Sahara (MINURSO) was sealed. 

While the US/Morocco’s level of diplomatic overreach shocked many, few of us who have been following the diplomatic theatrics surrounding Western Sahara predicted this outcome. There are lessons that can be learned from this saga. The US’ usurping of the UN’s mediation role and attempt to deliver Morocco a total diplomatic victory was a miscalculation. Security Council dynamics are complex. Russia, for its own reasons, was never going to allow the US to create such a precedent. 

A resolution of the conflict was never going to come from an imposition by the US in the Security Council. A lasting resolution can only come from within the Maghreb region, not New York, not Washington, nor through a shady deal. Coercing parties into agreement is never sustainable. Mediation efforts must be impartial, inclusive and regionally driven, if they are to succeed. Many of us have argued the UN and the Secretary-General’s good offices could have played a more meaningful role in ending the conflict, if they had been consistent with their own mediation principles that were hardly observed — such as inclusivity and national ownership. An end to the conflict will only come from a genuine dialogue between Morocco and Sahrawis and direct negotiations between Algeria and Morocco. And it’s time for civil society in the Maghreb to step up and play a facilitation role — they may succeed where governments have failed. 

Claims that the conflict is almost settled are misleading. On the contrary, now, after more than 50 years, the conflict is back to square one and the prospects for peace are bleaker than ever before. The current ceasefire rests on unilateral pledges. There is no independent verifier on the ground and no impartial, credible and active mediation underway. The risk of miscalculations and escalation is now very high.

Meanwhile, the US and Israel’s war against Iran seems to be stuck in the same old loop. In early November, Qatar mediation efforts produced a two stage plan that focused on trading International Atomic Energy Agency access to bombed nuclear sites in Iran, in exchange for an end to the US naval blockade and the release of frozen Iranian funds. However, the deadlock continues. The US insists on nuclear concessions before the talks go further and Iran insists that talks will only resume when it has verified its conditions have been fulfilled. 

It seems that both sides are intent on a deal but they differ on what comes first and verification. However, US President Donald Trump has appeared to put the kibosh on further negotiations, ordering the Vice President JD Vance to focus less on Iran and more on corruption and crime at home. With the US mid-term elections delivering a victory to the Democrats and Benjamin Netanyahu possibly on his way out in Israel, will the Trump administration’s approach to Iran shift?

Not far away in the Middle East, US, Russian and Ukrainian representatives met in Abu Dhabi, for the first time since February. While US officials have said they were seeking a “final end” to the conflict, it seemed the talks only reached limited agreements on prisoner exchanges with no signs of a ceasefire. Ukraine insists that the talks should become multilateral with Europe having a seat at the table but Russia continues to be opposed to the idea.

And the race for the position of the Secretary-General continues, with Rebecca Grynspan Mayufis, Rafael Grossi, and Caroline Rodrigues Birkett appearing to be the frontrunners. However, it would only take one P5 member in the Security Council, producing a red ballot to put them out of the race. In recent years the UN has become a diplomatic sandcastle, its principles vulnerable to being smashed down by members of the Permanent Five.

With negotiations over major conflicts now unfolding in the Middle East, mediation is shifting away from New York and the United Nations. A new Secretary-General will inherit an office  with a large bureaucracy to manage conflict but whose good offices role has been effectively outsourced. Will the next SG change this?

In this edition of Diplomacy Now we feature two articles on the Secretary-General race from a UN expert and former diplomatic insider. We also feature a deep dive into the renewed conflict in Tigray and the rising tensions between Eritrea and Ethiopia and an unpacking of the unceremonial end of MINURSO in Western Sahara. The edition concludes with an article on ongoing conflict in Yemen and rising attacks, along with an article on recent Russia-Ukraine negotiations. 

As with every edition the views expressed by contributors are not all necessarily our own. However, ICDI remains committed to the ethos and philosophy that open debate, dialogue, diplomacy, and mediation, rather than armed conflict and war, offer the way forward to resolving any conflict.

Thank you for reading Diplomacy Now and we welcome your feedback at diplomacynow@dialogueinitiatives.org. 

Jamal Benomar
Chair of ICDI

The UN Needs a New Blueprint

Professor Alanna O’Malley explores the political dynamics that are shaping the UN Secretary-General race and the desire for a more inclusive global body, stirring within the Global South. 

“It is clear that the UN is pivoting on a precipice of change in which leadership of the organization will be decisive. While the current candidates have each espoused elements of a vision for its future, what seems to be at the center is the notion of a more equitable global system. The scale of global crises represents a moment that demands a new blueprint for an institutional global order that puts the principle of equity at the center of UN politics,” Professor O’Malley writes.

How the UN Secretary-General is Really Chosen

Former British diplomat, whistleblower, political advisor and writer, Carne Ross, offers an insider’s account of how the UN Secretary-General is chosen – and bullied into compliance by members of the Permanent Five. 

“The appointment process appears sort of open, sort of vaguely democratic, at least a real choice of the UN member states. The SG is then treated as a kind of independent voice and authority in the world, whose judgements and condemnations matter. Indeed, the posture of what is often mistakenly called ‘the UN’ is treated as sacred by many otherwise right-thinking people, when in fact they respecting decisions more or less approved by Beijing, Moscow and Washington,” Ross writes. 

“We need a staunch and brave voice speaking up for the unlawfully killed, the deliberately-starved civilian, the tortured political activist – the international rule of law. Unfortunately, the SG is unlikely to be that person. Instead, it’s safer to regard them as a kind of symbol of the current geopolitical status quo who speaks accordingly,” he concludes. 

Tigray: Can Peace Be Brokered This Time?

Nairobi based analysts Matthew de Waal and Ngala Chome offer a deep dive into the Tigray conflict and the rising tension between Ethiopia and Eritrea. They also explore the mediation possibilities in a time of ‘political famine,’ adding Washington and the Gulf nations might be the only mediators with enough leverage.  

“The return to war comes as no surprise; it is a continuation of the last destructive conflict, but with a stunning reversal of alliances and perhaps more at stake,” de Waal and Chome write. 

“Realism is thus required. The immediate task is less to reach a settlement than to create space for mediation within Ethiopia, as well as deter a further slip towards war between Ethiopia and Eritrea,” they write.

The UN and Western Sahara: The Inevitable Conclusion of a Disaster Foretold

Former senior UN diplomat on Western Sahara Anna Theofilopoulou explores the diplomatic moves that paved the path for the ‘unceremonious’ end of The United Nations Nations Mission for the Referendum in Western Sahara, arguing that the Trump administration went a “little too far” in its backing of a Moroccan proposal on the disputed region. 

“[T]he mission’s termination was ushered in when both the US and Russia voted ‘no’ in quick succession for each other’s draft resolutions, thus dashing the hopes of the people of Western Sahara who have been vying for independence for more than 50 years,” Theofilopoulou writes.   

“The details that have leaked about the Moroccan expanded proposal make it sound like an effort to convince Moroccan citizens that Western Sahara is no different from the rest of Morocco’s regions and it will be treated by the central government as such… [T]he Moroccan proposal sounds unconvincing,” she writes.

The War Saudi Arabia Cannot Win

Middle East and Iran analyst Sina Toossi speaks with ICDI’s Jamal Benomar about the escalating conflict in Yemen between the Houthis and Saudi Arabia, a conflict he argues cannot be solved militarily. 

“The Saudi record of military intervention offers little reason for confidence in its ability to defeat the Houthis. Its 2015–22 campaign failed to reverse the Houthi takeover of Sanaa. Even direct US military intervention has failed to decisively weaken the movement,” Toossi argues. 

“Saudi Arabia has legitimate security concerns. Houthi missile strikes endanger civilians, and the movement’s repression of political opponents cannot be ignored. Yet prolonged military campaigns have not only failed to deliver the security Riyadh seeks but have arguably backfired catastrophically on the kingdom” he writes.

No Breakthrough in Ukraine Talks, but Europe May Return From the Cold

Bo Petersson looks at the recent US-facilitated talks on the Russia-Ukraine war held in Abu Dhabi that seemed to yield little beyond a prisoner exchange. However, Europe’s participation was a notable shift. 

“Europe’s participation in the talks is not a marginal issue, particularly as the position of the US as an honest broker has become debatable, given the tendency of the Trump administration to side with Russia on essential issues. Trump’s recent remark that Ukraine might “end up with a little bit different shape” after the war suggests this remains the case,” Petersson writes. 

“The Abu Dhabi meeting has at least revived negotiations between the two warring parties. But it is far from evident that peace has moved any closer,” he writes. 

Latest News

If you want to make peace with your enemy, you have to work with your enemy. Then he becomes your partner.

Nelson Mandela